By Rollevo ·
To handle an unpaid invoice dispute, confirm the line item and amount the customer challenges, assign a decision owner, and give the customer a date for the next update. Ask whether accounts payable (AP) can process any undisputed amount while the review is open.
Confirm what the customer is disputing
Ask for the invoice number, line item, amount, and reason for the dispute. A rate mismatch, duplicate charge, missing purchase order, and claim that the work was incomplete each need different evidence. If AP says the invoice is on hold, ask whether it needs paperwork or whether the customer is challenging the charge.
Open a dispute record and assign the decision
- Record the starting point. Log the total open balance, the amount under review, the person who raised it, and the date. Pause the standard reminder for the disputed amount while the issue is reviewed.
- Pull the source records. Check the contract, rate card, PO, delivery confirmation, or approved timesheet. For a short payment, also check how accounting applied the remittance.
- Name the decision owner. Billing can check invoice math. Operations can verify delivery or hours. An authorized person should approve any credit, revised invoice, or change in terms.
- Confirm what can move forward. Ask AP whether it can process the undisputed amount separately under the agreed process. Record the answer and set a dated next action.
What evidence should you ask for?
- Wrong rate or hours: compare the signed rate card or change order with the approved timesheet and billed line.
- Duplicate invoice: identify both invoice numbers and compare the billing periods, service lines, and payments already applied.
- Work or delivery challenged: check the agreed scope and the acceptance record. Ask the account owner to document any gaps and the proposed resolution.
Example with a partially disputed staffing invoice
AP disputes $900 on a $6,400 staffing invoice because the overtime rate differs from the approved rate card. The account manager compares the signed rate card with the approved timesheet. Billing owns any approved correction. The AR owner asks AP whether it can process the remaining $5,500 and records when the account manager will update AP. If AP's portal holds the whole invoice, the weekly report shows the full $6,400 exposed to the delay and the $900 actually disputed.
Subject: Review of invoice [number]
Hi [name], thanks for flagging the [line item]. We’re reviewing the [amount] against [source record] and will update you by [date]. Can your team process the remaining [amount] while that review is open?
Close the dispute and resume follow-up
- Customer is right. Have billing issue the approved correction or credit, reconcile the old and new balances, and confirm which invoice and due date AP will use.
- Customer is partly right. Write down what you agreed to adjust and what remains payable. Confirm whether AP can release the undisputed portion and record both amounts until the books reflect the decision.
- Records support the original charge. Explain the decision with the supporting line or document. Ask AP to confirm payment timing or identify the specific issue still blocking approval.
- Neither side agrees. Send the contract, invoice versions, evidence, and correspondence to the decision owner. Check the contract’s notice and dispute-resolution process. Ask U.S. counsel about formal next steps when the balance or relationship warrants it.
Record the decision, the version of the invoice that AP will process, any approved credit, and the updated payment timing. Confirm that AP has the final paperwork. Keep the decision and the payment as separate events in the weekly AR report. Use the payment reminder templates once the balance is ready for follow-up.
For an example of how an accounting system tracks invoice-related claims, see the Oracle Receivables guide.